Black Magic chocolate cookies with peanut butter chips stacked on a white surface

Black Magic

$30.00
(2 reviews) Write a Review
Availability:
Orders must be placed by 10 AM PT to qualify for the earliest available ship date.
Shipping:
Monday - Thursday
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Chocolate peanut butter chip cookies:

Chocolate and peanut butter, peanut butter and chocolate…? Who cares, I need some!

 

 

We Customize, with a heart-shaped cookie

2 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Black Magic Review

    Posted by Amber H. on Mar 16th 2026

    Black Magic cookies by In the Black Cookies is by far my favorite cookie! If I could only have one cookie for the rest of my life…this would be it!

  • 5
    Must Haves

    Posted by Shenelle on Nov 26th 2022

    These cookies are absolutely to die for. I order them for myself whenever I buy cookies for someone as a gift! The chocolate to peanut butter ratio is on point and always give that satisfying melt in your mouth feeling.

Nutrition Facts

Nutrition facts label for the Custom Black Magic Cookie Box
Nutrition facts label for The Black Magic Large Cookie Box
!